Introduction
Since the outbreak of the COVID-19, or Corona, pandemic, New Atheists have become increasingly active online on social media. But who is a New Atheist? A New Atheist is a follower of the philosophy known as New Atheism, which is arguably a more innocent term for Antitheism, or opposition to God. The Got Questions website points out that Antitheists are the “scoffers” or “mockers” mentioned in Psalm 1:1 and 2 Peter 3:3. They are not simply old-school atheists. After all, most atheists do not hate God because you cannot logically hate someone whose existence you completely deny. Unfortunately, the average Christian may respond to a New Atheist in the same way he would respond to an atheist, as illustrated by Mark 5:40 and Acts 17:16-21, because many Christians do not understand the difference. This approach is misguided. While atheism attempts, however imperfectly, to reason toward the conclusion that God does not exist, New Atheism often expresses itself through contempt, ridicule, and blasphemy. Therefore, Christians need to respond to New Atheists differently. In this message, I want to present a threefold, passive response to New Atheists. If the word “passive” surprises you, keep listening, and you will understand why.
The distinction matters because the Christian response should match the nature of the person and the conversation. We should not automatically treat deliberate mockery as though it were an honest intellectual inquiry. A sincere atheist may question God’s existence, challenge Christian beliefs, or raise difficult objections while remaining willing to listen and consider evidence. A New Atheist, however, may approach faith primarily with hostility and contempt, making productive discussion difficult or even impossible. This is why Christians must exercise discernment rather than assuming every unbeliever needs the same response. Scripture gives principles for dealing with mockers while calling us to remain faithful, gracious, and prayerful toward unbelievers today. The purpose of this message is not to encourage Christians to become hostile toward New Atheists, nor to avoid every difficult question. Instead, it is to show why a different, more measured response may sometimes be necessary when discussion becomes blasphemous mockery. This threefold response may appear passive, but it is neither cowardly nor indifferent. It is deliberate, disciplined, and firmly rooted in sound, practical, biblical Christian wisdom. As we examine these principles, we will see why Christians should respond carefully rather than react emotionally whenever New Atheists attack or ridicule God.
Read 2 Timothy 2:23-25
1. Don’t reason with a Mocker
I learned long ago never to wrestle with a pig. You get dirty, and besides, the pig likes it. George Bernard Shaw expressed a lesson that remains relevant when discussing people who reject reasoned dialogue and prefer mockery over conversation about faith, evidence, and truth. Two thousand years ago, Jesus conveyed a similar principle when He said, “do not throw your pearls to pigs” (Matthew 7:6). The point is not to insult people, but to recognize that valuable truth can be wasted when offered to someone determined to trample it. Blasphemy often becomes the new atheist’s preferred defense strategy when he cannot adequately answer a Christian argument. Consequently, attempting to reason through every belief with such a person can become like wrestling with a pig or placing precious pearls before one. Rather than engaging honestly with evidence, Scripture, and reason, the discussion may descend into mockery, contempt, and deliberate provocation. This is particularly evident when the subject turns to suffering, evil, or divine providence. Even a deadly pandemic such as COVID-19 or Corona can become, for the new atheist, another opportunity not for thoughtful questioning, but for ridicule and blasphemy against God and Christianity. It is a warning about discernment.
For instance, an atheist might argue that if God exists, He should not permit the outbreak of an evil pandemic such as COVID-19 or Corona. This argument at least attempts to raise a philosophical question concerning God’s existence, goodness, sovereignty, and the problem of evil. It can therefore be addressed through reason, theology, Scripture, and discussion. The new atheist, however, may take a different approach. Instead of asking questions or examining answers, he may resort to sarcastic and blasphemous rhetoric designed to ridicule faith itself. He might say, “When COVID-19 strikes, science becomes an elite soldier while God becomes a toddler hiding under Momma’s skirt!” Such a statement does not demonstrate that God does not exist, nor does it explain why suffering is incompatible with belief in God. It merely substitutes mockery for argument. Christians should therefore distinguish between sincere intellectual objections and deliberate contempt disguised as intellectual criticism. The former deserves a response; the latter may deserve silence. Jesus’ warning in Matthew 7:6 reminds believers that not every person who demands an answer is seeking truth. Sometimes wisdom means recognizing when engagement will produce neither understanding nor edification, and choosing instead to preserve the pearls entrusted to us.
Application:
Proverbs 26:4 gives believers an important warning about engaging in arguments with people who are determined to reject wisdom: “Do not answer a fool according to his folly, or you yourself will be just like him.” Applied to the new atheist who approaches Christianity with contempt rather than genuine curiosity, this principle reminds us that reasoning can sometimes become meaningless and unproductive. When a person has already decided that every Christian explanation must be ridiculed or dismissed, attempting to convince him of the truth can consume large amounts of time and energy without producing understanding. This does not mean that Christians should fear questions, avoid intellectual discussion, or refuse to defend their faith. Rather, it means recognizing when a conversation has ceased to be an honest search for truth and has become an exercise in pointless argument. Wisdom requires discernment. Not every challenge deserves an extended response, particularly when the person asking the question has no intention of considering the answer. In such circumstances, continuing the debate may accomplish nothing except frustration and unnecessary conflict. Proverbs therefore encourages believers to recognize the difference between sincere questioning and foolish contention, responding appropriately rather than allowing hostile arguments to control their attention.
For this reason, Christians should not feel obligated to throw their pearls before swine by attempting to explain every aspect of the COVID-19 or Corona pandemic through the Christian doctrine of suffering to someone who has already rejected the framework needed to understand it. Jesus said, “Do not give dogs what is sacred; do not throw your pearls to pigs” (Matthew 7:6). The imagery is intentionally strong because it emphasizes the value of what is being offered and the danger of placing it before those who will only trample it. The Christian doctrine of suffering addresses profound questions concerning sin, human freedom, a fallen world, God’s sovereignty, and the hope of redemption. Yet expecting someone who approaches these truths with contempt to appreciate or embrace them may be unrealistic. We do not expect a pig to understand the value of a pearl, nor should we expect someone committed to mocking Christian doctrine to recognize its beauty because we provide a longer explanation. The issue is not that Christianity lacks answers; rather, the problem is that some people refuse to listen. Therefore, believers should exercise wisdom, conserve their time and energy, and entrust truth to those genuinely willing to hear.
2. Don’t defend the Lord
The Gospel is like a caged lion. As Charles Spurgeon famously observed, it does not need to be defended; it simply needs to be let out of its cage. Yet Christians sometimes treat God as though He were a fragile, wounded kitten requiring constant nursing and protection. God does not need our protection. Someone might argue that if apologists defend God, there is nothing wrong with ordinary believers doing the same. However, there is an important distinction: apologists defend the faith, not God Himself. God needs neither defenders nor lawyers to preserve His honor, authority, or existence. Scripture illustrates this principle powerfully in Judges 6:31, where Joash, Gideon’s father, confronts the mob demanding his son’s death. He challenges them, saying, “If Baal is a god, let him defend himself when someone breaks down his altar.” Joash’s argument exposes the absurdity of protecting a deity who supposedly possesses power. If Baal were truly divine, he would be capable of defending his own honor. The same principle applies even more profoundly to the true God. He is not dependent upon human strength, arguments, eloquence, or legal defense to establish His glory before the world. His power needs no human permission. Forever.
We should therefore be careful not to confuse defending the Christian faith with defending God as though He were vulnerable to human criticism. Scripture reminds us that God cannot be mocked: “Do not be deceived: God is not mocked, for whatever one sows, that will he also reap” (Galatians 6:7). A new atheist may ridicule Christianity, mock Scripture, or insult God, and such words can deeply hurt believers when they take those attacks personally. Yet the insults themselves cannot diminish God’s glory, weaken His authority, or injure His nature. God does not become less holy because someone calls Him unholy, nor does He become less powerful because someone denies His existence. Our responsibility is not to rescue God from criticism, but to proclaim His truth faithfully and confidently. Like a lion released from a cage, the Gospel does not require human strength to make it powerful. It possesses its own authority because it is the message of God. We may answer objections, correct falsehoods, and defend the truth of the faith, but we should never imagine that God Himself stands helpless before His critics. Our confidence should rest in Him, not in our ability to win every argument.
Application:
Often, when we take defensive positions in the name of God against blasphemy, we do so for the wrong reasons. We may convince ourselves that we are defending God, but the reality is that we are offended personally and ultimately end up defending ourselves. God does not need us to protect His honor through anger, hostility, or personal retaliation. Our response should reflect the character of the One we claim to represent. Furthermore, we must not stoop to the level of those who insult God by deliberately seeking to offend them in return. Jesus commanded His followers to love their enemies, not to wage crusades against them or become Christian Jihadists. Love does not mean approving blasphemy, abandoning truth, or remaining silent when Scripture is mocked. Rather, it means responding without hatred, vengeance, or the desire to humiliate our opponents. We can firmly uphold our faith while refusing to turn every insult into a personal battle. When we remember that God is sovereign and does not depend upon our anger for His defense, we can respond with greater wisdom, self-control, and grace. Our task is to represent Christ faithfully, not to avenge every offense committed against Him in every circumstance.
Likewise, humanity cannot fairly blame God for the COVID-19 pandemic. The deadly virus originated in a laboratory in Wuhan, China, and, in this sense, the pandemic resulted from human actions rather than something God deliberately did. Many recognize human responsibility. Yet some people remain determined to blame God, and those who are committed to doing so will often discover another reason to accuse Him. No amount of evidence, explanation, or theological clarification will satisfy someone who has already decided that God must be guilty. Therefore, we should not allow their accusations to drag us into endless arguments or provoke us into responding with anger. God is not threatened by human accusations, nor does He require us to defend Him as though His sovereignty depended upon our ability to win every debate. What matters is that we remain faithful, truthful, and composed. We should reject the temptation to retaliate simply because others attack what we believe. Instead, we can entrust the matter to God and continue living according to His Word. If God does not need to be consumed by their accusations, neither should we. Our responsibility is faithfulness, not outrage, revenge, or endless contention with those determined to blame Him.
3. Don’t cease to Intercede
Intercessory prayer might be defined as loving our neighbor on our knees. As Charles Bent expressed it, prayer becomes an act of love directed toward others who reject our faith. We should not attempt to reason endlessly with New Atheists when productive conversation is impossible, nor should we imagine that God needs our defense. God is capable of defending His truth and glory. Yet this does not mean we should ignore those who reject Him. Instead, we can and should intercede for New Atheists just as we pray for our atheist friends. Scripture calls us to seek the salvation of those who are lost. Acts 26:18 reminds us that people need to be turned from darkness to light and from the power of Satan to God. Prayer therefore gives Christians a response when arguments fail. Rather than responding to hostility with hostility, we can simply bring unbelievers before God, asking Him to reveal His truth, soften hardened hearts, and draw them toward the Gospel. Intercession keeps our focus where it belongs: not on winning arguments, humiliating opponents, or defending God, but on loving people enough to ask God to save them. It teaches humility, patience, compassion, and dependence upon Him.
There are three reasons to pray for New Atheists and atheists alike. First, we ourselves were saved by grace, not because we were holier or more deserving than others. If you believe in God today, someone prayed for your salvation, and that should produce humility. Second, nothing is impossible with God when we believe and pray. Through prayer, we ask the Holy Spirit to convict the hearts of New Atheists and make them more receptive to the Gospel. We cannot force anyone to believe, but we can place them before the One who can transform hearts. Third, while we may distinguish between theist, atheist, monotheist, polytheist, New Atheist, or antitheist, God sees something deeper: a soul created in His image and personally considered worth dying for. Christ died for that soul. Prayer is therefore both a passive and active response to New Atheists. We do not confront them, insult them, or attempt to correct objections in prayer. Yet prayer is among our most powerful weapons, and its power has been demonstrated throughout history. When arguments reach their limits, intercession remains an expression of genuine love, faith, dependence, and hope in God. It allows us to seek their salvation without hostility.
Application
The Word of God, in 1 Thessalonians 5:16-18, urges believers to pray without ceasing. This command remains important even when answers seem delayed or circumstances appear discouraging. We should never allow unanswered prayers, disappointment, or prolonged waiting to weaken our commitment to prayer. Whether God answers a particular request, when He answers it, and how He answers it belong entirely to Him. These matters are His business, governed by His wisdom, sovereignty, and perfect purposes. Our responsibility is much simpler: we are called to continue praying faithfully. Intercessory prayer is not merely an activity we undertake when convenient; it is part of God’s expressed will for His people. Therefore, frustration should not cause us to surrender, and disappointment should not persuade us that prayer is useless. Instead, delays should deepen our dependence upon God and strengthen our willingness to persevere before Him. Faithful prayer trusts God even when circumstances provide no immediate evidence of an answer. We may not understand His timing, but we can trust His character. At every stage and season of life, prayer teaches us to place our requests into His hands while continuing to believe that He hears, cares, and works according to His perfect will.
God is never too early or too late, because He is always in control. His timing may differ from ours, yet His sovereignty is never threatened by circumstances, uncertainty, or delay. Even the COVID-19/Corona pandemic is under His control. Although events can appear chaotic, nothing lies beyond God’s knowledge, authority, or ability to act. We therefore have reason to remain confident in Him, even when we cannot understand what He is doing. God is also the God of creativity, and His answers to prayer demonstrate that divine creativity. He does not have to respond according to the limited possibilities we imagine. His solutions can emerge through unexpected circumstances, people, opportunities, or developments that we could never have anticipated. Indeed, God’s answers may be so creative and extraordinary that they surpass our imagination. Every time He answers prayer, the answer is unique because God knows precisely what is needed and understands circumstances more completely than we do. Consequently, believers should not attempt to dictate how God must respond. Instead, we should pray faithfully, trust patiently, and remain open to His unexpected ways. The God who hears our prayers is capable of accomplishing far more than our limited understanding can foresee.
Conclusion
Scripture teaches in 1 Peter 3:15 that believers should always be prepared to explain the hope and beliefs they hold. Yet this instruction does not mean every discussion with an unbeliever will be fruitful. There is an important distinction between an atheist, a New Atheist, and an honest seeker. New atheists commonly embrace antitheist convictions, opposing not merely belief in God but religion itself. An antitheist rarely identifies himself openly by that label; instead, he may describe himself as a New Atheist or as someone committed to New Atheism. In practice, antitheism and New Atheism can function as two sides of the same coin. New Atheism has frequently relied on ridicule and contempt toward religious faith, to the extent that even some unbelievers have criticized it as intellectually and philosophically shallow. Therefore, discerning a person’s attitude is essential when discussing faith. An honest seeker may question Christianity because he genuinely wants answers, while an antitheist may approach the conversation primarily to attack or ridicule belief. Christians should therefore recognize that explaining the truth requires wisdom, discernment, patience, and humility, especially when engaging people whose hostility extends beyond simple disbelief or honest intellectual questioning. Such discernment helps believers respond wisely and faithfully.
The character of New Atheism can often be recognized through the behavior of its advocates. Richard Dawkins, whom New Atheists regard as a leading figure, mocked the Roman Catholic doctrine of transubstantiation at the 2012 Reason Rally and encouraged participants to treat religious beliefs with contempt. Likewise, in 2015, Stephen Fry expressed hostility toward God during a television program, describing God as a “maniac.” Fry has identified himself with New Atheism, and in 2018 he received the Richard Dawkins Award for his lack of religious faith. Such examples illustrate the distinction between traditional atheism and the more confrontational posture associated with New Atheism. An atheist may simply lack belief in God without directing hatred, ridicule, or contempt toward God or religion. For instance, atheist Penn Jillette is not known for making blasphemous attacks against God or religious people merely for their beliefs. The distinction matters because Christians should not approach every unbeliever in the same manner. A sincere atheist may be willing to discuss evidence, philosophy, and faith respectfully, while an antitheist may be motivated by hostility. Therefore, believers should answer according to the person’s attitude, remembering that God calls them to respond with reason, reverence, and readiness.
If you found this content helpful, I kindly ask you to leave your feedback in the comments section below. Sharing it with your friends and family through email or social media would also be greatly appreciated. Your feedback not only encourages me but also contributes to the growth and edification of the Church. In order to promote meaningful and respectful dialogue, I request that you use your full name when commenting. Please note that any comments containing profanity, name-calling, or a disrespectful tone will be deleted. Thank you for your understanding and participation.
